Joyce v. ARB Gaming LLC (Modo), B2Services OU (McLuck), Affirm et al. + JAMS award (update to baseline)
Operators and lenders exploited his gambling addiction; seeks $10.5M from Modo, $1M from McLuck and $1M from Affirm.
Details, rulings and takeaway
- Status
- Pending in court; arbitration ended in ARB's favor.
- Filed
- 2025-06-30
- Docket
- 2:25-cv-01868-DJC-CSK (E.D. Cal.); JAMS Ref. 5100003080
- Operator group
- ARB Gaming, LLC / ARB Interactive, Inc. (Scottsdale, AZ); B2Services OU · B2 group · ARB Gaming
- Brands
- Modo.us, McLuck
- Other defendants
- Affirm, Inc.; Apple; Goldman Sachs Bank USA; interpleader by Jamie Stahura
- Plaintiff / agency
- Matthew Joyce (North Carolina resident; later pro se)
- Plaintiff counsel
- Law Office of Reshma Kamath (initially)
- Claims and theory
- Illegal gambling; predatory lending / BNPL; Unruh Act, UCL and other California claims; breach of contract; unjust enrichment; negligent and intentional misrepresentation
- Rulings timeline
- 2025-05-09: his counsel filed a JAMS demand
- 2026-03-04: arbitrator denied motion to declare arbitration non-binding and dismissed California-law counts with prejudice (Arizona choice of law)
- 2026-04-06: Joyce tried to withdraw all claims
- 2026-05-13: interim award for ARB
- 2026-09-04: final award for ARB on all four remaining claims (no merits ruling; withdrawal barred by JAMS Rule 13(a))
- 2026-09-28: court allowed ARB to file the award and gave Joyce 30 days for a 5-page response; ARB's motion to compel and Affirm/Apple motions to dismiss still pending
- Money
- Damages sought $12.5M total; award: nothing to plaintiff
- Takeaway for counsel
- Once a player starts arbitration, JAMS rules can stop them from walking away; arbitration choice-of-law clauses can strip state consumer claims.
- Last checked
- 2026-10-08
